Best Thrift Stores in NYC: A Comprehensive Guide to Top Thrifting Spots in the Big Apple

New York City, the city that never sleeps, is also the city that never stops thrifting. From high-end vintage boutiques to budget-friendly chain stores, NYC offers a plethora of options for thrift enthusiasts. I remember my first thrifting adventure in NYC vividly. I was exploring the East Village and stumbled upon a tiny, unassuming shop tucked between two bustling cafes. Inside, I found a treasure trove of vintage designer pieces at prices that were just too good to be true. That serendipitous find not only made my day but also ignited a passion for NYC's vibrant thrift scene. Whether you're on the hunt for unique fashion pieces, rare collectibles, or everyday bargains, this guide will take you through the best thrift stores in the city. We'll cover best clothing thrift stores in NYC. Let's dive in!

Best Thrift Stores in NYC

Best Thrift Store for Clothes Shopping

1. Beacon's Closet

Beacon's Closet operates 4 branches across New York City. The largest of these is situated in Brooklyn’s Greenpoint neighborhood, known for its expansive layout and diverse selection. Established in 1997, Beacon's Closet first opened its doors in Williamsburg, Brooklyn. Each branch provides amenities like free Wi-Fi, a customer service desk, and a comfortable seating area. They are well-regarded for their buyback program, allowing customers to sell their items directly to the store, which has received high praise in online reviews.

For shoppers, the price range is typically between $10 and $200, catering to a wide spectrum of budgets. Sellers can expect competitive offers, with items generally priced from $15 to $150, based on condition and market demand.

Website Information: Beacon's Closet Website

2. L Train Vintage

L Train Vintage has 7 branches scattered across New York City. The largest location is in Williamsburg, renowned for its extensive array of vintage items and roomy interior. Since its inception in 2008, the chain’s first store opened in the East Village. The stores feature free Wi-Fi and a customer service desk. Notably, they offer a rotating sale on select items, a service highlighted positively in customer reviews.

For buyers, prices are generally between $10 and $40, offering great value for vintage clothing enthusiasts. Sellers find competitive pricing here, with items often fetching between $15 and $50, depending on their condition and appeal.

Website Information: L Train Vintage Website

3. Buffalo Exchange

Buffalo Exchange boasts 6 branches across New York City. The largest branch is located in Williamsburg, known for its vast collection and ample space. The store began in 1974, with its original location in Tucson, Arizona. In NYC, branches offer amenities like a customer service desk and frequent promotional events. They are known for their rewards program, which has been positively reviewed by customers.

Buyers will find prices ranging from $15 to $100, making it ideal for those seeking trendy and affordable fashion. For sellers, the store offers competitive rates, with items generally priced between $20 and $80, influenced by the item's condition and demand.

Website Information: Buffalo Exchange Website

Best Thrift Store for Furniture

4. Housing Works

Housing Works operates 9 branches across New York City. The largest branch is in SoHo, recognized for its extensive selection of furniture and home decor. The chain started in 1990, with its first branch opening in the East Village. Facilities include free Wi-Fi and a café, with additional amenities such as donation pickup for larger items. This service has received positive feedback for its convenience and impact.

From a shopper's standpoint, prices vary from $20 to $200, appealing to both budget and high-end buyers. Sellers benefit from competitive pricing, with items often selling between $30 and $150, depending on condition and desirability.

Website Information: Housing Works Website

5. Awoke Vintage

Awoke Vintage has 3 locations across New York City: the flagship store in the Lower East Side, which is the largest and most spacious; the Williamsburg branch, known for its curated selection and vibrant shopping experience; and the Greenwich Village location, offering a more intimate shopping environment with a well-chosen assortment of vintage clothing and accessories. Established in 2016, Awoke Vintage quickly gained recognition for its commitment to sustainability and unique fashion finds. The stores offer amenities such as knowledgeable staff, frequent in-store events, and a comfortable atmosphere.

Prices typically range from $25 to $150, catering to those who appreciate well-preserved vintage clothing. For sellers, the store provides fair compensation, with items generally valued between $30 and $120, depending on their condition and rarity.

Website Information: Awoke Vintage

Best Thrift Store for Books

6. Cure Thrift Shop

Cure Thrift Shop has 1 branch in New York City, located in the East Village. This store is distinguished by its broad selection of books and eclectic inventory. It started operations in 2008, with its first branch opening in the East Village. Facilities include free Wi-Fi and a cozy reading nook. They are known for their book donation drives, which have been positively noted by customers.

For buyers, prices range from $15 to $75, catering to those looking for both affordable and unique finds. Sellers find competitive pricing, with items typically selling between $20 and $70, depending on their condition and rarity.

Website Information: Cure Thrift Shop

Additional Notable Mentions

7. 10 ft Single by Stella Dallas

10 ft Single by Stella Dallas operates 1 branch in New York City. The largest store is in Williamsburg, famous for its extensive range of vintage clothing and accessories. The store began in 2006, and its Williamsburg location is a notable favorite among vintage enthusiasts. The store offers facilities like a customer service desk and vintage repair services, which have been positively reviewed.

Prices range from $20 to $150, providing options for both budget shoppers and those looking for unique finds. Sellers benefit from competitive pricing, with items generally selling between $30 and $100, depending on their condition and appeal.

8. Crossroads Trading Co.

Crossroads Trading Co. has 4 branches in New York City. The largest branch is located in Chelsea, renowned for its extensive collection of high-quality and trendy items. The store, which began in 1991, first opened in Berkeley, California. In NYC, branches offer a customer service desk and regular sales events. They are known for their trade-in program, which allows customers to exchange items for store credit, a feature that has received favorable reviews.

Prices range from $25 to $150, appealing to those seeking fashionable and designer pieces. Sellers enjoy competitive pricing, with items generally priced between $30 and $120, based on their condition and brand.

Website Information: Crossroads Trading Co.,

Thrifting in NYC is an adventure, with each store offering its own unique selection of items and shopping experience. Now wrapping up, if you’re looking to sell your clothes, I definitely recommend Beacon's Closet or Buffalo Exchange, but if you’re seeking high-end designer pieces or trendy fashion, independent boutiques like Awoke Vintage are the places to go. Ready to start your thrifting adventure? Grab your tote bag and hit the streets of NYC to discover these fantastic thrift stores. Happy hunting, and don't forget to share your best finds with us!

Frequently Asked Questions and Answers:‍

1. What should I bring when visiting a thrift store in NYC?

• Answer: It's helpful to bring a reusable tote bag for your purchases. If you're selling or consigning items, ensure they are clean and in good condition. Cash and credit/debit cards are typically accepted, but check in advance if you're visiting a smaller store.

2. Do thrift stores in NYC offer returns or exchanges?

• Answer: Most thrift stores have a no-return or exchange policy due to the nature of second-hand items. Always check the store’s policy before making a purchase.

3. Can I donate items to thrift stores in NYC?

• Answer: Yes, many thrift stores, especially those run by non-profits, accept donations. Look for stores with donation drop-off points or inquire about their donation procedures.

4. How can I find out if a thrift store buys or consigns clothing?

• Answer: Check the store's website or contact them directly. Many stores have specific guidelines for consigning or selling items, including what types of clothing they accept and how the process works.

5. Are there any tips for thrifting in NYC?

• Answer: Visit stores during off-peak hours for a more relaxed shopping experience. Check back frequently, as inventory changes regularly. Be patient and open-minded—sometimes the best finds are hidden among the racks.

‍